Why is it okay to make assumptions online?

Sarah Allen • March 14, 2018

Answer: It's not!

What has happened in our online world where we feel it is ok to judge, make assumptions and sometimes be down-right rude to each other? The moral code we follow in our off-line world seems to be forgotten as we quickly respond and send! It seems, to me, to be the modern version of road rage! In a car we might swear and interact aggressively with some one who cuts in front of us but if someone bumped into us in the street the most likely response would be to apologise (even if the other person bumped into us!). The security of the car around us can stop us connecting with the other road users and the same goes to interacting online. When you reply to a stranger, you see their name and their profile picture but do you see that they are a fellow human-being?

So why am I writing this? You've guessed it I have been subjected to people making and expressing certain assumptions about me. And lets be honest here, it's not nice! I'm not traumatised, it's not ruined my day however there is a little niggle there! I said to a friend yesterday, that it didn't bother me that it was "Water off a ducks back!", so why am i still thinking about it today?

Those of you who follow my work, will know I am passionate about reducing the amount of rubbish I throw away and trying to elliminate unnecessary plastic from my life. This doesn't seem like too much of a controversial idea and in the main it isn't. However, for a few people, this is a problem to them. This is completely fair enough, I am not asking you to agree with me, I am simply sharing what I do. Don't get me wrong, it's lovely when people do support me, I have had so many positive comments online. People have encouraged me and many tell me they have changed some of the things they do as a result of what I am sharing. This is amazing, I truly do want the planet to be a better place for all living things, including humans. I am not writing for this approval but when I get it, I'm not going to lie, it feels great!

Then there are those 'other' comments. I was going to say I feel lucky that I don't get them very often. But is 'lucky' the right word? I don't feel lucky that I didn't have to deal with unkind comments on the school run this morning, I would say my expectation was for, at least, civil interactions! I am also 'lucky' that comments haven't been too personal in their attack, unlike other comments I've seen online. For example, a woman was told online that she looks like an old hag (she was in her thirties, not that it is okay to say to someone older!) and she should dye her greying hair. Would you say that to someone in the queue in Tesco? So, in my 'luckiness' or most likely my lack of exposure online my looks have not been attacked but people have made assumptions and voiced them. These are some recent comments (all linked to my concern about non-recyclable or unnecessary plastic):

"If you have enough time to collect plastic for a month, you could do something constructive, collect for charity or help someone"

"Read Tesco's sustainability policy and educate yourself with facts instead of being just another plastic bandwagon jumper!!"

"So much time so little to do"

"I think you are quite misinformed about the recycling process and how it works"

"Just shows how much you clearly don't care about the environment... You are just one of the many people who are merely jumping on the bandwagon".

"You are saying you buy this for convenience."

Not the worse comments I've ever heard but complete strangers feel it's ok to assume I do nothing worthwhile in my time, I do no charity work, I don't help people, I have not educated myself with the facts, I don't care about the environment, I am jumping on a 'bandwagon' and I buy products for convenience without thinking about the impact of that purchase. I have never had a stranger say this to me face, so why say it online?

This is not a serious issue for me but it will make me think carefully about sharing posts. I already have self-edited and avoided certain FB groups or pages. This, in a way, is fair enough if you write you do need to think about the audience but should people's assumptions really silence others?

I know for most writers it is a scary business pressing 'publish' on a blog post. As a human you are sharing a piece of you, its a creative process, it might say something about you personally and you have invested time and energy into it. I started writing about 18 months ago after being a runner-up in a competition. The judges believed in me so I started to believe in myself. It's been amazing, I've loved the creative outlet, I love how it gives me clarity of thought, me-time, a chance to be in a 'flow' activity, a chance to interact, to learn from others and grow as a person, as an environmentalist (I guess that's what I am if I care about the environment) and as a parent (another topic I write about). Step by step I have grown in confidence and publicised my work more but now I feel the need to be more careful, to consider if I can handle the assumptions before I hit publish (which is what I will be doing with this piece; maybe this will end up as a personal reflection rather than a public blog post). I think this isn't uncommon, with all creative work there has been critics but it's a recent phenomenom that everone can be a critic easily using their devices and hitting send. Feel free to have an opinion about what I am saying, I welcome that, a healthy discussion can help us all grow. However, if you wouldn't come up to me in the street and say it or if it's based on your assumptions about me perhaps you should think twice before you hit the send button.

I don't feel I have to address the assumptions above. I don't have to justify myself. However, I just wanted to mention the woman with the greying hair. She isn't dyeing it because she has a life-limiting condition and she and her husband want to feel like they are growing old together. So, how about thinking before you press 'post' or, you know, it is possible to just scroll past!

Have you had any experience of being affected by people's assumptions online, I'd love to hear about it in the comments.
A little disclaimer: This is in no way directed at my lovely Rhubarb and Runner Beans followers, you are awesome, polite, supportive and inspirational. All the assumptions I have shared came from posting on other Facebook pages.


By Sarah Allen July 16, 2025
2nd May 2027
By Sarah Allen June 20, 2025
Are there really beavers living close to where I live?
By Sarah Allen October 1, 2024
My shoulders ache; my body is tired. The smallest of tasks feel mammoth. My body craves rest but my mind has different ideas. It wants me to think, work out what to do, problem-solve and worry. I fight to quieten it but the truth is I haven't enough energy. I haven't even enough energy to put on a load of washing in the machine but my kids need clean school shirts. I haven't enough energy to make packed lunches but my kids need to eat. I check what homework they have got, lay the table for dinner, load the dishwasher, make sure the guinea-pigs are fed. My husband, thankfully, makes dinner otherwise I don't know how we would eat. The entire day is like walking through treacle. I cry in sheer exhaustion. The bare minimum is too much. Then I repeat this day after day, year after year. This is surviving, getting through each moment, each day, each year until many have passed and I can no longer remember how living truly feels. How it felt to have cancer-related fatigue and cancer-related PTSD. Thankfully, I don't have many days like this any more, though I can have a run of them during times of stress, when menstruating and after socialising (I'm still not used to it and find it very tiring). The cancer-related fatigue has gone but my energy levels are still a lot lower than they were before my cancer diagnosis and I'm impacted by PTSD on an, almost, daily basis. This has lessened and is becoming more manageable but is triggered by stress and tiredness. You can see the cycle I can get trapped in here. I'm sharing this during Breast Cancer Awareness Month to raise awareness of the long-term impacts of being someone who has had cancer. Also, please check your breasts /chest. It's tough living with the impacts, mostly mental and emotional now, of cancer but I'm, of course, very grateful to be here. Early detection of cancer means outcomes are likely to be better. I found my breast cancer by chance whilst washing . Don't leave it to chance, check today and make it a monthly routine.
By Sarah Allen September 6, 2024
In a world of car-dominating towns and cities, what happens if people, plants and animals are put first?
By Sarah Allen May 6, 2024
By Sarah Allen April 30, 2024
I'm eating it, crunching it between my teeth. It's on my coffee cup, it's in my hair and my eyes. My phone has a sprinkle of it's grittiness and so has my coat! It's covering the road and is continuing to swirl across from the beach, Coating my camper van, no doubt! The beach has been flattened. It looks smooth and new. Footprints covered as soon as they are made. A few brave walkers head into the wind, hoods up and heads bowed, Walking with determination. Nature is powerful and strong in all her wildness.
By Sarah Allen April 26, 2024
I'm going to share a little about my garden, in case you are interested and so you might be able to support me in rewilding it and making it more nature friendly. The back garden is mostly lawn. We need to keep it that way as half of it is used for the guinea-pig run, rotating it every few days. This half has currently got lots of lesser celandine, which are good for pollinators. The plant mostly dies off by the time its warm enough for the guinea-pigs to be outside. I have to pull up any remaining plants and anything else that is toxic for them to eat. The other half is wilder and left uncut. A greater variety of plants grow including daisies and ragwort. We keep it as lawn so a tent can be put up for the kids. I also like to put a blanket down and sit on it (once it's drier). Around the edges of the lawn is left fairly wild but we also grow strawberries. The strawberry patch was used by hedgehogs last year to forage for invertebrates, I should think because it was unweeded it provided a lot more for them. Though, I may have to weed it a bit this year to allow the strawberry plants to grow. The front garden was block paved by previous owners. I've got pots growing food and some with flowers. I'd like to increase the amount of food I grow in this area. I use the front garden for this as it has lots of sunshine. I'd also like to increase the plants for pollinators and have bees and butterflies constantly flying from flower to flower. That's me, how about you? What's your garden like? Extract from the Changemaker membership which I run from my Patreon page (there's also a private FB group). We are starting our new focus: Rewilding our gardens and incorporating rest as we move into the, often, busier seasons of spring and summer. It's a form of gentle activism within a supportive community and you're invited! Join for 7 days (it's free!), a month, all spring or more. Any questions? Just ask.
By Sarah Allen January 22, 2024
This was a pilgrimage I took last year at Imbolc. I found using the energy of the rising spring was the right time to think about the new year and to let go of some of the things that were no longer serving me. 
By Sarah Allen January 2, 2024
By Sarah Allen November 30, 2023
Show More